But Wait, There's More is a game about advertising. Specifically, it's about those terrible late night shopping ads. The idea is pretty simple, a product card is selected for the round - it might be a knife, it might be a frying pan, it might be a wagon. Then all the players select a feature from their hand of cards - possibly 'remote controlled', maybe 'with wheels' and has thirty seconds to improvise an ad for the resulting product. At some point, they MUST say 'But Wait, There's More!' and draw a random feature card, whicb must be added to the product. So you could end up advertising a remote controlled wagon... WITH WHEELS! At the end of each round, players vote on which they thought was the best ad.
So, what was changed for the Kickstarter version?
Well, for a start, all the product and feature cards are new. This cuts both ways - I play with a teen aged group, and some of the old features, such as 'closed circuit TV' and 'closed captioning' kept giving them trouble. A few other features were a bit old school, thanks to the march of technology. 'With QWERTY Keyboard' is probably not such a selling feature anymore. On the whole, the feature cards now read like sales pitches, instead of just naming a product. This helps integreate them into your pitch faster, and they are all now things which you would expect to see on late night shopping ads. The thing is, far fewer of them make sense with the products. Since the whole point of the game is advertising ridiculous combinations this isn't too bad.
The voting mechanic has also changed. In the past, each player had one vote, which they gave to the best ad in that round. The winner was the first to win three rounds. Now, each player is dealt a hand of vote cards each round, and gives their favourite speach the '3 votes' card, their next favourite the '2 votes' card, and so forth. The game ends after three rounds, and votes are totalled up. I like this system more - it means you can reward more players, and it also means there is more tension since no one knows how many votes they have until the end of the game when the cards are turned over and totalled.
Another very handy addition to the game is the egg timer. It's a little thing, but since this is a boxed game, not a Print and Play anymore, they can include an egg timer which makes things easier. Timing 30 seconds on a phone was always a bit of a pain, the egg timer is much more convenient and easier to see for all players.
With the changes to the core mechanics of the game out of the way, what else has been added? Well, the kickstarter includes one new mechanic, and an expansion. The new mechanic is the 'Tell us more' card. This card goes to the player who's birthday is closest, and can be played after any other player's ad. Basically, the victim of the card has to turn over a third feature card and keep going. They can then keep the 'Tell us more' card and use it when they want. The expansion, called 'That's the best part' adds a set of yellow cards. Each player gets two of these at the start of the game, and they are not replaced during play. They are also played after an ad, and all ask a question such as 'what happens if I eat it?'. Then you have to say 'That's the best part...' and turn the problem into a selling point. There is no limit to the number of these cards you can have played on you - I have had a round go for almost five minutes having been hit with 'Tell us more' and six or seven 'That's the best part' cards. It was an amazing product, but it gave me a sore throat...
The PNP version of But Wait, There's More was a popular fixture of Gippsland Gamers. The Kickstartered version looks like taking on the very same place in our hearts. The game is always highly entertaining, it never outstays it's welcome, and it's very easy to learn. This is currently my favourite party game, but that might be somewthing to do with being a Media/English teacher. The new version tidies things up, has excellent presentation, and comes with the excellent expansions AND the invaluable egg timer - what more could a man want?
THE VERDIT:
But Wait, There's More (Toy Vault edition) scores:
Clarity of rules:
Learning curve:
There's really not much to learn, and it can be easily and quickly explained in a minute or two. The real trick lies in learning how to speak for thirty seconds - once you get that timing right there's no stopping you.
Fun:
Like all party games, this would depend on your group. People who do not like to talk will hate this game, but with the right group it's amazingly entertaining. Our group does contain some fairly shy people who dislike public speaking, but when we play, they tend to get caught up in the fun and really get into it. Obviously, this game requires a certain level of speaking skill, it's not something you should play with small children for instance.
Replay Value:
Sure, there are a limited number of combinations in the product and feature cards, but the number is pretty damn huge. We've been playing this game every other week or so for over a year, and I still get loud requests for it to hit the table. Sometimes we play two or three times in a night. Any game which involves crazy combinations of unlikely things tends to be pretty replayable, and this one is no exception.
Presentation:
The box is solid, the cards are colourful, the text is clear. The presentation is not going to set the world on fire, but it does it's job. The old PNP used a bunch of different fonts on the feature cards, the new version sticks to just one, which helps clarity. The only thing which annoys me is that the cards are all the mini sort, and I find them hard to shuffle... It's a bit bland, but you're not really looking at the components, you're listening to the other players, so it doesn't hurt the game.
